Articles i found interesting, things that are funny for me, my beliefs, philosophy in life and other things about me.
Does Total Freedom Exist?
Published on February 2, 2004 By EFalgui In Philosophy

Have you ever asked yourself this question? If not, then you should ask yourself now. Because this is probably one of the questions that will shape what and who you will be.

But before going forward we first must know what freedom is and the difference between the freedom of nature and the freedom of a person.

There is genuine freedom in the world. When we observe it from the outside, it takes the form of unpredictability; when we observe it from within, we call it our free will. We know that the reason why our behavior is unpredictable from the outside is that we have ultimate freedom of choice. This freedom is the very essence of our personalities, the treasure of our lives. It is given us as the first element of the world we come into.

Since I am talking about freedom concerning humans, then it is free will that we will be talking about.

I believe there are three basic positions that one can adopt on the question of free will: either we have absolute free will, or we have no free will at all, or we have a certain measure of free will.

I myself believe that we can with proper constraints such as rules and laws etc. Without such constraints our society would be in total chaos. Another factor to consider is that freedom rests in the principal of respect for other people—that of which each and every human being is of equal value—irrespective of race, gender, religion, sexuality—or anything else.


This states that no person is an object to be used simply as a means to some other end. That is, all people have a basic degree of dignity that is denied when we use them merely as a tool for our own purpose.

Therefore we should not only protect our own freedom but those of other people as well. In helping other people gain freedom, we ourselves get a bit more freedom through our actions.

Nature too comes into the picture. For example, we cannot change the past, breathe under water, or fly like a bird. These constraints though are already so natural for us that we rarely pay any attention to them.

In addition to these physical/natural limitations, there are also psychological limitations on our freedom: our mental conditioning and our numerous habits and instincts play a major role in determining our actions.

I have to admit that I myself have lost control or succumbed to irresistible urges, to have been impelled by some unknown/unconscious motives and desires that I didn’t know I had. But I feel that most of the time we do freely choose our own actions, and that some of the impulses we have can be resisted if we put our minds to it.

As for destiny, I believe in self-made destinies. Fashioned by our desires, forged by our wills. Our lives are not governed by outside forces where we have not played a part in creating. But these outside forces do affect our lives. In the very end thought is in the choices that we make, whether we have mean and selfish or noble and altruistic, that gives meaning to this life of ours. Freedom for me is never for the weak of will, anyway those kinds of people never have freedom anyway since they are the type of person that does whatever the masses is doing. That for me is the worst choice one can make. Doing something just because other people are doing it. For me it just doesn’t make sense and probably never will.

Anyway this is already pretty long. About 1 out of 15 people who will look at this would even read this till the end so ill end this article with this. The greatest freedom one can have is in serving the greater good. Anyway goodbye all.



"We can never be truly free unless we give others the same freedom we would want to have for ourselves."

Edmund Falgui

PS I know its a bit vain for me to quote one of my papers but thats what i am, vain and narcissistic. But i would like to believe i am also a good person after alls been said and done.
Comments
on Feb 02, 2004
Ah, so you do have a name. This is well thought out. I don't totally agree with it. In the Christian religion there is a debate between Calvinism which says that we gave up our freedom when Adam sinned and Arminianism, which states that we can say yes or not to God. Neither philosophy considers that we have a lot of freedom. Just try to break a bad habit. Some are easy, others are almost impossible.

Keep on writing about freedom. It is an interesting topic.
on Feb 04, 2004
Great topic. I don't know about free-will and its' relation to freedom of action though. Here's an account to consider:
As a kid this guy goes and makes a bad decision and ends up getting hit by a car. Trashes his leg, ends his career plans. Years go by, he has a limp, but can walk. One night he's walking down a deserted street and a guy shoots at him; tries to shoot him right in his face from 50 yards. He feels the bullet go by his ear, hears the sound, then the ricochet as it flies on down the street having barely missed him. Consider this:
Because he had a limp, as the guy pulled the trigger with him right in the sight perfectly, his weight shifted and his body moved ever so slightly off-sight. The bullet missed and he lived. Now, was it free will when he made his bad decision and got hit by the car all those years before? Maybe it was all in a grand plan involving knowledge of what would happen in his life and a god made the wreck happen so he could limp as the bullet was fired at his head years later. Sometimes we don't know or remember that all things happen in their time and place so God, or some other THING, will be glorified.
I once sat on a bus and watched a poor mother get on with her two year old. The kid was truly ALIVE, standing on the seat and taking in everything around him as the bus rode on. I could see his mind racing as he took in the whole experience. He turned and looked at me and I saw genius in his eyes. He was a clearly superior human and fully living every second with his senses on fire for understanding. When my stop came I got up and walked past the poor mother, who was sitting quietly revelling her moments of peace, as only a parent knows when the kids are young. I told her, "Maam. Your child has highly intelligent eyes. He has the eyes of a genius." and then left the bus. It occured to me as I stepped off though, that I may now be hit by a car this moment and my whole life was to learn all I had and be able to observe the kid and bring to the attention of a mother who never realized it, how special and genius her own Son was. Maybe that kid would grow up and cure cancer or save the earth, and my role had been served to make that simple statement and then pass on.
Do we truly have free will? Or is there an order or plan to all we do that is so complex and awesome we cannot even conceive of but a portion of it? The argument 'for' is the argument 'anti', and we're stuck in this world never truly knowing till we are gone and see it from a new cognitive-lense.
Thanks for the read. Blog ON.
on Feb 04, 2004
I think i can understand what you mean. Fate or destiny for me are only guidelines which we can choose to follow or not to follow. for example i believe me and my ex girlfriend was fated to meet each other at the time we met, but it depended on me whether to court her or not. anyway for me i guess the only thing i can say is that i believe i have the freedom choose my actions and with that belief i am content.
on Feb 04, 2004
This is a very interesting subject! I believe with all of my heart that everything happens for a reason.
on Feb 04, 2004
Arthur C Clarke is quoted as saying "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

By analogy, I ask - does it matter whether we truly have "free will", or if instead there is a greater purpose or destiny which is incomprehensible ?

So Edmund, lets assume you knew with *certainty* that you don't in fact have free will and that every action is pre-destined - Would you behave any differently? Would you make different choices?

on Feb 05, 2004
Ok let me get this straight. your asking me to make a choice when it is certain that all choices are already predetermined. if its already predetermined then how can one make a choice about it?

the only solution i can see for this problem is if there was more than one pre-destined path for each person. i myself believe in God but if this destiny thing is true then why did God even create this universe if he already knew how it would turn out.

anyway my answer would probably be do as i always have done. if i knew for certain that everything i would do is pre-destined, then why the heack would i change it simce it would mean nothing for me to do it any other way.
on Feb 05, 2004
RIGHT!!!

I actually think your reply is typical and that is why I asked it (and hence the quote)

It's one of those deep, confusing, meaningful questions, that I've also pondered, but in the end I realized I WOULDNT BEHAVE ANY DIFFERENTLY!! So really in some sense it doesn't "matter" (even if it is interesting). Is it magic, or the man behind the curtain?

To illustrate your point further and bring it back to your original post:

"We can never be truly free unless we give others the same freedom we would want to have for ourselves."

Arguing free will OR destiny you can support or refute this:

Free Will: "Why treat others well - they have a choice - let them help themselves - if they are in trouble, it must be something they did"

Destiny: "What does it matter how I treat them - if it is destined to turn out right, it will, if not, they deserve it"

(I think your previous argument is convincing for the pro side so I wont repeat it)

So in the end... it doesn't matter. We must dig deeper to find reason in why we should treat others with dignity and compassion. Ponder this..

Thoughts ?
on Feb 08, 2004
I guess the best reason if you need one for treating anyone with respect and compassion is that in turn they will also give you what you gave them. if not then it doesnt really matter does it, because then i would know that i shouldnt waste my time with them.

in the end it really depends on each of us to do what is right for ourselves. anyway if they turn out to be assholes thats when i bring out the guns and pop a cap in their asses. but in all seriousness they wouldnt be worth shit in my eyes.
on Feb 08, 2004
Great article, it's a shame that so many people believe that freedom can be dictated by so few under their terms, and when these are no met that freedom is forfited.
on Oct 02, 2004
Only the rich and the powerful deserve to have freedom.